رقابة القاضي الإداري على الغلو في القرار التأديبي

- Books

i. Abu Amer ,Muhammad Zaki, 1986, Penal Code, General Section, Dar al matbuaat al jameaa, Alexandria.

ii. Abd al-Barr ,Abd al-Fattah, 1996, Some Aspects of Appeal against the Administrative Decision in the Judiciary of the State Council, Journal of Administrative Sciences, published by the Egyptian Division of the International Institute for Administrative Sciences, Year 38, Issue 1.

iii. Abdel-Aal ,Mohamed Hassanein, 1971, The Idea of the Reason in the Administrative Decision and the Case for Cancellation, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabia, Cairo.

iv. Ahmed ,Mohamed Sayed, 2008, The Proportionality Between the Disciplinary Crime and the Disciplinary Punishment with Application to Police Officers and Public Employees, Faculty of Law, Assiut University.

v. Al-Ajarmeh ,Nofan, 2007, Authority to Discipline Public Employees - A Comparative Study, First Edition, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Amman, Jordan.

vi. Abu Dan ,Maya, 2011, Judicial Control over Proportionality in Administrative Decisions, first edition, Dar Al moasasa alhadeetha , Tripoli, Lebanon.

vii. Bi Tikh, Ramadan, 1996, Developing Trends in the Judiciary of the French Council of State to Limit the Authority of the Administrative Discretionary, Cairo, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

viii. Al-Fauri, Fathi, 2004, The Principle of Proportionality between the Disciplinary Violation and the Disciplinary Punishment, Journal of Security Studies, Jordan, Issue 1 .

ix. Gazi, Haitham Halim, 2010, Disciplinary Councils and Supervision of the Supreme Administrative Court, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami`, Alexandria.

x. Hajja Abdel-Aali, and Tammam, Amal Yaish, 2008, Monitoring the Appropriateness of the Administrative Decision and Its Place in the Cancellation Case, Legal Forum Magazine, Fifth Issue, University of Mohamed Kheidar Biskra, Algeria.

xi. Al-Hayassat, Ahmed, 2015, Disciplinary penalties imposed on public servants and the impact of their exaggeration on the disciplinary decision, Dar jamaat Naief , Riyadh.

xii. Ezzat ,Fahmy, 1980, Disciplinary Authority between the Administration and the Judiciary (a comparative study), Dar alam al-kotob, Cairo.

xiii. Jabr ,Mahmoud Salama, March 1993, The State Council’s Oversight of the Administration’s Manifest Error in Adapting and Estimating the Facts in the Cancellation Case, Journal of the State Cases Authority, Year 37, Issue 01, Cairo.

xiv. Jamal Al-Din ,Sami, 1991, Judgment of Convenience and the Discretionary Authority of Administration, Cairo, Dar Atlas.

xv. Al-Jahmi ,Khalifa, 2009, Judicial control over the proportionality between punishment and crime in the field of discipline, Dar Al-jamaa Al-jadeeda.

xvi. Kanaan ,Nawaf, 1999, Administrative Judiciary Oversight of the Principle of Proportionality in Disciplinary Decisions - A Comparative Study in France and Egypt. And Jordan (Yarmouk Research - Humanities and Social Sciences Series: Jordan) Volume 15.

xvii. Khalifa ,Abdulaziz, 2008, Guarantees of Legality of General Administrative Penalties, first edition, Dar Al-markez Al-qawmi.

xviii. Qidar Salih, Naktel Ibrahim, Exaggeration in the Administrative Decision, Al-Rafidain Journal of Law, Volume (18), Issue (64), Year (20).

xix. Al-Tamawy ,Suleiman, 2006, The General Theory of Administrative Decisions - A Comparative Study, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo.

xx. Al-Tamawy, Suleiman Muhammad, 1987, Administrative Judiciary,Book Three, Disciplinary Judiciary, A Comparative Study, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo.

Legislations

i. The Jordanian Civil Service System and its amendments No. 9 of 2020, Official Gazette No. 5619, Page 697, 2/2/2020

ii. Jordanian Administrative Judiciary Law No. 27 of 2014, issued in Official Gazette No. 5297 dated 08/17/2014 on page 4866.

Decided Cases

i. Judgment No. 593, 2021, 15/ 02/2022 by the Jordanian Administrative Court.

ii. Judgment No. 618, 2021, 15/ 02/2022 by the Jordanian Administrative Court

iii. Judgment No. 45, 2022, 29/ 03/2022 by the Jordanian Administrative Court

iv. Judgment No. 664, 2021, 14/ 02/2022 by the Jordanian Administrative Court

v. Judgment No. 2, 1957, 12/ 02/1957 by the Jordanian Administrative Court

vi. Judgment No. 593, 2021, 15/ 02/2022 Jordanian Supreme Administrative Court

vii. Judgment No. 74, 1985, 27/ 11/1985 Jordanian Supreme Administrative Court

viii. Judgment No. 361, 2000, 22/ 01/2001 Jordanian Supreme Administrative Court

ix. Judgment No. 94, 2000, 28/ 06/2000 Jordanian Supreme Administrative Court

French References

i. C.E 12-1-1938, Coulangoon, C.E 29-10-1948, Maussac,C.E 21-4-1950, Cicquel.

ii. Ou’entin II n’appertien pas a la jurldiction administrative d’apprecier la Gravite’e de lasanction disclplinaire infligue Ou requerant m’est pas a ces regard de macbe. ’ de dectournement Ou pouvoir.

iii. André Delaubadère, Yves Gaudement, Traite Droit Administratif, tome1,libraire general de droit de jurisprudence,16èdition, Paris,1999.

iv. Jacqueline Morand-Devili: Cours de Droit Administratif, Montchrestien, 6 édition, Paris, 1999.