اختصاص مجلس الدولة في تطوير النظام الانضباطي

First: Legal books and references

I. Dr. Ahmed Khorshid Hamidi - Dr. Saddam Hussein Yassin, Iraqi Administrative Judiciary, 1st ed., Dar Al-Masala, Baghdad, 2019

II. Dr. Taghreed Muhammad Qaddouri, The Principle of Legitimacy and Its Impact on the Disciplinary System of the Public Service, 1st ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Lebanon, 2013.

III. Dr. Hamed Shaker Mahmoud Al-Taie, Notary Publications in Judicial Reasoning (A Comparative Analytical Legal Study), 1st ed., Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, 2018.

IV. Dr. Hassan Abdullah Younis, Judicial Developments, 1st ed., National Library and Archives, Egypt.

V. Hussein Abbas Abdul-Ilah, Objective and Procedural Controls for Administrative Investigation, 1st ed., Dar Al-Masala, 2024.

VI. Dr. Hussein Othman Muhammad Othman, Principles of Administrative Law, 1st ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Lebanon, 2010.

VII. Dr. Hamdi Abu Al-Nour Al-Sayed Awis, Advisory Management and the Role of the Judiciary in Supervising It (A Comparative Study), Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami’i, Alexandria, 2011.

VIII. Dr. Hamid Hanoun Khaled, Human Rights, 1st ed., Dar Al-Sanhouri, Beirut, 2015.

IX. Dr. Saeb Muhammad Nazim, Disciplinary Penalties and Judicial Supervision, 1st ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Lebanon, 2007.

X. Dr. Abdul Qader Al-Shaikhli, Legal Drafting (Legislative, Jurisprudential, Judicial, Advocacy), 1st ed., Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Jordan, 2014.

XI. Dr. Adnan Muhammad Abbas Dabo Al-Zaidi, The Role of the Iraqi Administrative Judiciary in Establishing the General Principles of Law (A Comparative Study), 1st ed., Library of Comparative Law, Baghdad, 2022

XII. Dr. Issam Abdul Wahab Al-Barzanji - Dr. Ali Muhammad Badir - Dr. Yassin Al-Salami, Principles and Provisions of Administrative Law, Al-Sanhouri Library, 2015

XIII. Dr. Esmat Abdel Majeed Bakr, State Council, 1st ed., Dar Al-Kotob Al-Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 2011, p. 210

XIV. Dr. Ali Saad Omran, Administrative Judiciary, 1st ed., Al-Radwan for Publishing and Distribution, Amman, 2016

XV. Dr. Fawzat Farhat, General Administrative Law / Part One, 3rd ed., No publisher, Beirut, 2017

XVI. Dr. Majid Muhammad Yaqout, Explanation of the Disciplinary Law for Public Service, Expanded Edition, Dar Al-Jamiah Al-Jadida, Cairo, 2009

XVII. Dr. Mazen Lilo Radi, Principles of Administrative Judiciary, 3rd ed., No publisher, Baghdad, 2016

XVIII. Dr. Mazen Lilo Radi, General Principles of Law in the French State Council Judiciary, 1st ed., Zain Legal Publications, 2020

XIX. Dr. Mazen Lilo Radi, The Disciplinary System, 1st ed., Dar Al-Masala, Baghdad, 2020

XX. Dr. Muhammad Abdul Hamid Abu Zaid, The Judicial Character of Administrative Law, 2nd ed., Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya for Publishing, Beirut, 1998

XXI. Dr. Muhammad Palestine Hamza, Aspects of Legal Security in the State Council Judiciary, 1st ed., Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, Egypt, 2022

XXII. Dr. Muhammad Maher Abu Al-Ainain, Al-Mufaddal in Discipline in Public Service and Disciplinary Councils / First Book, 1st ed., Dar Rawae Al-Qanun for Publishing, Egypt, 2020

XXIII. Dr. Muhammad Misbah Al-Qadi, The Right of a Person to a Fair Trial, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 1996

XXIV. Dr. Muhyiddin Al-Qaisi, General Administrative Law, 1st ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, 2007

XXV. Marwa Mahmoud Faris, The Interpretive Jurisdiction of the Iraqi State Council (Comparative Study), 1st ed., Dar Al-Masala, Beirut, 2021

XXVI. Dr. Mustafa Youssef, Disciplinary Responsibility of the Public Employee (Its Limits and Guarantees), No Edition, Maaref Establishment, Alexandria, 2010

XXVII. Dr. Maghawry Muhammad Shaheen, The Disciplinary Decision, Its Guarantees and Judicial Oversight between Effectiveness and Guarantee, No Edition, Cairo, 1986

XXVIII. Naseer Abbadi Hamoud, The Problem of Legal Guarantees towards the Decision to Impose Disciplinary Punishment on the Public Employee (Comparative Study), 1st ed., Center for Arab Studies, Egypt

Second: Theses and Dissertations

I. Mitham Faleh Hussein, Legislative Deficiencies in the Iraqi Penal Code, PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, Al-Nahriya University, 2018

Third: Published research

I. Dr. Ahmed Kamal Abu Al-Majd, The constructive role of administrative judiciary between formal and substantive doctrines in law, a research published in the Journal of Law and Economics, Cairo University Press, Vol. 32, No. 3, 1962

II. Dr. Hanan Muhammad Al-Qaisi, The scope of the fatwa jurisdiction of the State Shura Council, a published research, Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, Issue 17, 2018

III. Dr. Haider Ghazi Faisal, Legislative shortcomings in the Iraqi Code of Criminal Procedure, a published research, Journal of Law and Political Sciences, University of Iraq, Volume 20-6, Issue 15, 2022

IV. Dr. Zana Raouf Hama Karim, Rayen Abu Bakr Omar, Aspects of the Legislative Role of the State Council, Published Research, Journal of the University of Human Development, Volume (8), Issue (1), 2022, Published on the website (https://journals.uhd.edu.iq/index.php/juhd/article/view/940/667)

V. Dr. Samia Ochan, Interpretation of the Administrative Judge of Legal Texts and Its Impact on Filling the Deficiencies in Administrative Law, Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, Algeria, Issue 17, 2018, Published on the website (https://www.asjp.cerist.dz/en/article)

VI. Dr. Taima Al-Jarf, The Judiciary is a Constructive Source of Administrative Law, Journal of Government Cases, Issue 4, Year 6, D-T

VII. Dr. Abbas Al-Aboudi, The role of the Federal Court of Cassation’s rulings in formulating the legal rule, published research, Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, Volume Thirty, Issue Two, 2015

VIII. Dr. Abdul Hussein Abdul Nour - Dr. Rasha Abdul Razzaq, Justifications of the State Council in interpreting the legal rule, published research, Al-Muhaqqiq Al-Hilli Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, Issue One, Year Five, 2023

IX. Omar Hammad Saleh - Dr. Ali Fawzi Al-Moussawi, The importance of the independence of the Iraqi State Council, published research, Journal of Legal Sciences, University of Baghdad, Volume 37, Issue One, 2022

X. Dr. Mazen Lilo Radi, Judicial Security and the Role of Ijtihad in Administrative Judiciary, published research, Journal of the State Council, Volume One, Issue (Zero), Year One, 2023

XI. Dr. Muhammad Madi, Criminal Protection for the Implementation of Rulings and Decisions of the Administrative Judiciary in Iraq, published research, Journal of the State Council, Volume One, Issue (Zero) Year One, 2023

XII. Dr. Maha Bahjat Younis - Jihad Ali Juma, The Judicial Jurisdiction of the State Shura Council and its Role in Protecting Public Rights and Freedoms, Published Research, Journal of Legal Sciences, University of Baghdad, Volume 34, Issue 3, 2019

XIII. Dr. Wissam Sabbar Al-Ani, Sovereignty Acts in Light of Legislative and Judicial Development in Comparative Systems, Published Research, Journal of Legal Sciences, University of Baghdad, Volume 29, Issue 2, 2014

Fourth: Published Articles

II. Dr. Ali Hadi Al-Hilali, The Authority Competent to Interpret Legal Texts in Light of the Federal Supreme Court Decision No. 48 of 2021, an article published on the website (https://www.iraqfsc.iq/news.4733

III. Najlaa Ahmina, Justifications for the Constructive Role of the Administrative Judge, an article published on the website (https://espaceconnaissancejuridique.com/2024/02/20K (

Fifth: Constitutions

I. The Egyptian Constitution in force for the year 2014, published on the website (https://www.constituteproject.org (

II. The Iraqi Constitution in force for the year 2005, published in the Iraqi Gazette in issue No. 4012 on 12/28/2005

Sixth: Laws

I. Iraqi Civil Law No. (40) of 1951 as amended, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (3015) on 9/8/1951

II. Lawyers Law No. (137) of 1965, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (1213) on 12/22/1965

III. Civil Procedure Law No. (83) of 1969 as amended, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (1766) on 8/10/1969

IV. State Council Law No. (65) of 1979 as amended, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (2714) on 6/11/1979

V. State and Public Sector Employees Discipline Law No. (14) of 1991, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (3356) on 6/3/1991

VI. Federal Supreme Court Law No. (30)

VII. For the year 2005 as amended, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (3996) on 3/17/2005

VIII. Private Higher Education Law No. (25) of 2016, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. 4416 on 9/19/2016

IX. State Council Law No. (71) of 2017, published in the Iraqi Gazette No. (4456)

X. Egyptian State Council Law No. (47) of 1972, published on the website https://marsd.daamdth.org/2018/03/23))

Seventh: Judicial Groups

IV. Collection of State Council Decisions and Fatwas for the year 2017, State Council Publications,

V. Collection of State Council Decisions for the year 2018, State Council Publications,

VI. Collection of State Council Decisions and Fatwas for the year 2019, State Council Publications

VII. Collection of State Council Decisions and Fatwas for the year 2020, Iraqi State Council Publications, Modern Waqf Applicator

VIII. Collection of State Council Decisions and Fatwas for the year 2021, State Council Publications

IX. Collection of State Council Decisions and Fatwas for the year 2022, State Council Publications.

X. Supreme Administrative Court Ruling No. (157/Year 2 Q) on 6/2/1959, Collection of Principles Decided by the Supreme Administrative Court, First Year.