The Moral Element of the Crime of Genocide and the Challenges of Proving “It Palestinian Case Study”
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35246/me3anq12Keywords:
Genocide, moral element, criminal intent, criminal proof, international criminal lawAbstract
This research aims to study the moral element in the crime of genocide, especially the special criminal intent in this intentional crime, and the challenges that make proving it extremely complex in the Palestinian case. This research followed the descriptive analytical approach. The research problem lies in the main question: How can the moral element, especially the special intent, in the crime of genocide be identified and proven in the context of the Palestinian situation? What are the challenges of applying the rules of evidence associated with it? The research reached the following conclusions: The moral element is considered the essential element in describing the crime of genocide, especially proving the special criminal intent that distinguishes it from other international crimes. Proving the moral element, especially special criminal intent, in the crime of genocide requires adopting an approach that combines behavior analysis, government policies, military documents, and speeches of incitement. The study recommends calling on the Palestinian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, in cooperation with the Ministry of Justice, to establish a national body for international criminal documentation that would collect evidence related to international crimes, particularly genocide, in accordance with the procedural and evidentiary rules adopted before the International Criminal Court. Calling on the Palestinian Ministry of Justice and the International Crimes Prosecution to prepare comprehensive legal files on the crime of genocide, based on evidentiary evidence derived from an analysis of the inflammatory rhetoric of Israeli leaders and officials, the long-standing policies adopted against the Palestinian people, and the patterns of criminal acts. Calling on the State of Palestine to form international alliances with countries that support the rights of the Palestinian people and international justice to confront the Israeli narrative and break the political hegemony that Israel uses to justify genocide.
Downloads
References
I. Amnesty International. (2024, December). Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza: “You feel less than human.” Amnesty International Retrieved November 13, 2025, from https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/12/amnesty-international-concludes-israel-is-committing-genocide-against-palestinians-in-gaza/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
II. International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, Case No. ICTR-96-3.
III. Kreb, Claus(2006). The Crime of Genocide under International Law, International Criminal Law Review,vol,6, no,p. 461-502.
IV. Office of the United Nations Special Adviser on the Prevention of Genocide. (2023). Analysis framework – Legal definition of genocide. United Nations. Retrieved from https://docslib.org/doc/6593500/office-of-the-un-special-adviser-on-the-prevention-of-genocide-osapg
V. Republic of Serbia. (2009). Counter-Memorial: Case concerning application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Croatia v. Serbia) (Vol. 1). International Court of Justice.
VI. Schabas, A.William.(2000). Genocide in International Law, Cambridge University Press.
VII. Sultany, N. (2024). A threshold crossed: On genocidal intent and the duty to prevent genocide in Palestine. Journal of Genocide Research, p.1-26.
VIII. Travis, H. (2021). Ethnic cleansing and genocidal intent: Conceptualizing destruction of local populations. Washington University Global Studies Law Review, 20(3), 803-862.
IX. Van Santen, B. (2025). Demonstrating genocidal intent before the ICJ. New York University Journal of International Law and Politics, 57, 155–194.
X. ثالثا_ المراجع العربية مترجمة:
XI. Al-Ash'al, Abdullah. (2009, November 09). This is how the Zionist entity justifies its crimes in Gaza? Al-Mahjah Magazine. https://arab-scholars.com/31d7c1
XII. Bashar, Nabil.(1994). International Responsibility in a Changing World, 1st ed., Mansoura Press.
XIII. Jad, Mohammed.(2025). The crime of genocide between the duality of theoretical criminalization and practical impunity, Journal of Legal and Economic Studies, Volume 11, Issue 2, pp. 2714-2753.
XIV. Al-Janaini, Alaa.(2024). The crime of genocide and its punishment in international law with application to Gaza as an example, Journal of the College of Sharia and Law, Tafhana Al-Ashraf, Part Four, pp. 4385-4450.
XV. Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics.(2025). The Wounded, retrieved 11/10/2025, through: https://www.pcbs.gov.ps/site/lang__ar/1406/Default.aspx
XVI. Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics.(2025). Martyrs, retrieved 11/10/2025, through: https://www.pcbs.gov.ps/site/lang__ar/1405/Default.aspx
XVII. Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics.(2025). Demolished buildings, retrieved 11/17/2025, by: https://www.pcbs.gov.ps/site/lang__ar/1408/Default.aspx
XVIII. Hijazi, Mahmoud (2006). Combating International Terrorism between International Law and State Practice, ed., Al-Ashry Press, Cairo.
XIX. Hussein, Hayat.(2022). The problem of proving criminal intent in the crime of genocide, Journal of Law and Political Science, University of Khenchela, Volume 9, Issue 2, pp. 111-131.
XX. Dahiliya, Jude.(2021). The Crime of Genocide in International Law, Master's Thesis, An-Najah University, Palestine.
XXI. Al-Shawi, Sultan and Al-Warikat, Muhammad.(2011). General Principles in the Penal Code, 1st ed., Dar Wael, Amman.
XXII. Sharif, Kazem and Afan, Haider.(2023). Special Criminal Intent in the Crime of Genocide, Journal of the Faculty of Law, Al-Nahrain University, Volume 25, Issue 1, pp. 283-314.Al-Shammari, Abdul Razzaq.(2022). The Crime of Genocide in International Criminal Law, Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut, 1st ed.
XXIII. Shams al-Din, Ashraf.(1999). Principles of International Criminal Law, second edition, Dar Al Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo.
XXIV. Amer, Salah al-Din.(1977). Armed Popular Resistance in Public International Law with Special Reference to the Foundations of International Legitimacy of the Palestinian Resistance, ed., Dar Al Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo.
XXV. Abdulkhaliq, Muhammad.(1989). International Crimes: A Fundamental Study of Crimes Against Humanity, Peace, and War Crimes, 1st ed., Dar Al Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo.
XXVI. Abusultan, Abdullah.(2009). The Role of International Criminal Law in Protecting Human Rights, First Edition, Dar Dijlah, Amman.
XXVII. Obaid, Hassanein.(1979). International Crime (An Applied Analytical Study), 1st ed., Dar Al Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo.
XXVIII. Al-Azzizi, Nabil.(2024). Public International Law and the Fight against Genocide (The Palestinian Question as a Model), Legal Journal, Vol. 21, No. 1, pp. 491-548.
XXIX. Al-Faar, Abdul Wahid.(1995). International Crimes and the Authority to Punish Them, no edition number, Dar Al Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo.
XXX. Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice on the Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Document No.: A/ES-10/273.
XXXI. Farajullah, Simon.(2000). Crimes against humanity, genocide, war crimes and the development of their concepts: in Studies in International Humanitarian Law, presented by Dr. Mufid Shihab, 1st ed., Dar Al-Mustaqbal, Cairo.
XXXII. Al-Qahwaji, Ali.(2001). International Criminal Law (The Most Important International Crimes, International Courts), 1st ed., Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications.
XXXIII. Landler, Mark. (2023, November 15). Erase Gaza: War unleashes fiery rhetoric in Israel. Palestinian Forum. Retrieved November 13, 2025, from https://arab-scholars.com/16b163
XXXIV. Metwally, Rajab.(2010). The difference between international terrorism and legitimate resistance in light of the rules of contemporary international law, without ed., without a publishing house.
XXXV. Human Rights Council.(2022). Report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem and Israel, Document No. A/HRC/50/21 issued on 9/5/2022.
XXXVI. Marei, Ahmed.(2012). Legal Defense in Light of Modern International Changes, PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, Cairo University.
XXXVII. Mansour, Mohammed and Qatari, Mohammed.(2017). Criminal, civil and international responsibility of perpetrators of genocide crimes before the judiciary, Journal of the Faculty of Sharia and Law, Tanta, Volume 32, Issue 3, pp. 804-901.
XXXVIII. Amnesty International.(2024). Genocide committed by Israel against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, Document No.: MDE 15/8668/2024.
XXXIX. Nazarene, Maryam.(2022). Special Criminal Intent in the Crime of Genocide in Light of the Rome Statute, The Thinker, Volume 17, Issue 1, pp. 376-398.
XL. Al-Naimi, Lahbib.(2024). Special criminal intent to exterminate protected groups, comparative legal and judicial interpretation, Arab Book Journal of International Law, Issue 4, pp. 173-186.
XLI. Human Rights Watch.(2024). Genocide and Acts of Genocide, USA.
XLII. Human Rights Watch.(2021). They crossed the line: the Israeli authorities and the crimes of apartheid and persecution.
Downloads
Published
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Copyright and Licensing:
For all articles published in Journal of Legal Sciences, copyright is retained by the authors. Articles are licensed under an open access Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, meaning that anyone may download and read the paper for free. In addition, the article may be reused and quoted provided that the original published version is cited. These conditions allow for maximum use and exposure of the work.
Reproducing Published Material from other Publishers: It is absolutely essential that authors obtain permission to reproduce any published material (figures, schemes, tables or any extract of a text) which does not fall into the public domain, or for which they do not hold the copyright. Permission should be requested by the authors from the copyrightholder (usually the Publisher, please refer to the imprint of the individual publications to identify the copyrightholder).
Permission is required for: Your own works published by other Publishers and for which you did not retain copyright.
Substantial extracts from anyones' works or a series of works.
Use of Tables, Graphs, Charts, Schemes and Artworks if they are unaltered or slightly modified.
Photographs for which you do not hold copyright.
Permission is not required for: Reconstruction of your own table with data already published elsewhere. Please notice that in this case you must cite the source of the data in the form of either "Data from..." or "Adapted from...".
Reasonably short quotes are considered fair use and therefore do not require permission.
Graphs, Charts, Schemes and Artworks that are completely redrawn by the authors and significantly changed beyond recognition do not require permission.
Obtaining Permission
In order to avoid unnecessary delays in the publication process, you should start obtaining permissions as early as possible. If in any doubt about the copyright, apply for permission. Journal of Legal Sciences cannot publish material from other publications without permission.
The copyright holder may give you instructions on the form of acknowledgement to be followed; otherwise follow the style: "Reproduced with permission from [author], [book/journal title]; published by [publisher], [year].' at the end of the caption of the Table, Figure or Scheme.
